February 7, 2024

10 CFO Performance Metrics: What Makes a Great Finance lead?


These 10 performance metrics indicate a great CFO. Fulfil these criteria, and you’re on track to lead your business to financial success. 

Miranda Gabbott

There’s no denying that the role of Chief Financial Officer comes with a lot of responsibility. You must keep one eye on the minutiae of the accounts, and one on managing your team—whilst having another eye in the back of your head on outside forces that might affect the business.

In a sense, as long as you’re keeping the lights on, you’re meeting the essential requirement to be a good CFO. But here are ten performance metrics that indicate a great CFO. 

10 CFO performance metrics: is your finance lead good at…

Whether you’re a CFO yourself, or a CEO looking to conduct a performance review of your second in command, here’s what you should look at to make your judgment. 

1. Managing the business’ finances?

Clearly, the business’ success or failure is not a CFO’s responsibility to carry alone. However, a good Finance Lead steers a business to fiscal health—or puts together a solid game plan if that doesn’t seem possible. 

With the caveat that some factors may be out of their control, you should assess your ability as a CFO partly on the business’ financial metrics, such as…

  • Profitability: the company's ability to generate profits over time. 
  • Revenue growth: the company’s top-line growth—and whether revenue has increased during a CFO’s tenure.
  • Cash flow management: a competent CFO will ensure that you’re always as liquid as you need to be by managing cash flow and working capital. 
  • Cost management: control of your expenses and operational costs.

2. Managing their team?   

As well as sitting alongside senior leadership, CFOs usually manage their own teams. Great finance leaders must also be great people managers, delegating important tasks to junior colleagues, and mentoring them to become proficient at business-critical tasks. 

A CFO can be extremely competent, but if their management skills fall short, a company won’t have the weight of a full, high-performing team behind its financial goals.

Qualitative performance metrics of a good team manager include: 

  • A low team turnover, and perhaps even a high rate of internal promotions. 
  • The whole team understanding their responsibilities for aspects of the company's financial operations—and colleagues on other teams also having visibility over which finance team member owns which duties. 
  • Taking ownership when things go wrong, and not passing blame to junior colleagues.

3. Managing stakeholders?

It’s essential for a CFO to be confident talking to anyone and everyone involved with the company’s financial activities. As the CEO’s right-hand person, you should have a warm professional relationship with the business’ bank, investors and board of directors. 

You should walk the line between being an active listener, and a persuasive leader: able to argue for your strategic vision without making important stakeholders feel unheard.

Performance goals for stakeholder management include:   

  • Sending regular, concise budget updates to the CEO, investors and the board of directors—on time and without being prompted. 
  • Proactively going to your CEO with news that they should know about, between reports. 
  • Flagging financial trends and strategy ideas in plenty of time. 
  • Anticipating questions that stakeholders might have, and preemptively pulling the data to answer them. 
  • Being a confident and convincing reporter, whether to investors or potential buyers of the business.

4. Data analysis? 

Strong data analysis skills are essential for a great CFO. Whether or not data really is “the new oil”, it is essential to stay across your financial statistics on a micro and macro level to make informed decisions. 

Whilst it was once enough to be a spreadsheet whizz, successful CFOs now almost always implement a suite of tools to help them spot patterns in the numbers. This is especially the case for finance leaders at SaaS companies, who manage the complexities of subscription-based customer relationships. On that note, here’s a rundown of 10 must-have software tools for CFOs. 

When CFOs are good at data analysis, they typically: 

  • Don’t rely on manual processes.
  • Organize their business’ financial KPIs on a dashboard which they can navigate with total fluency.
  • Select relevant KPIs to track and do not suffer from analysis paralysis: overwhelm from staying across too many data points. 
  • Know how to find the answer to almost every financial question the CEO asks—or can convincingly explain why that question isn’t relevant to the bottom line. 

5. Forecasting the business’ financial performance?

A good CEO should be able to predict the future—to the extent that this is possible, at least. With good data analysis skills, finance managers should be able to say with some degree of accuracy where things are likely to go next, so they can help the CEO plan accordingly. 

Metrics to appraise whether you are good at this include:

  • Do you use scenario modeling tools to predict the state of a companies’ finances, whether events unfold favorably or not? 
  • Do you present your CEO information about changes to the market which may affect the business’ operations?  
  • Do you accurately forecast budgets month-to-month, and plan the company resources accordingly? 

Did you know?: For most companies, software is the second biggest budget expense after payroll. Yet, tech spend is often very difficult to include in budget forecasts. That’s because licenses are usually managed by a range of stakeholders in different teams, and each tool has its own subscription cycle, with no central oversight. 

A software management tool like Cledara can give you total visibility over your software subscriptions, so that you can forecast their costs accurately and easily.  

6. Reporting on the business’ financial performance? 

CFOs must keep their stakeholders informed with clear and concise reports on the business’ financial health. They deliver these reports at regular intervals, and may even choose to send out two tiers of analysis: a high-level summary of important figures for board members, and a more granular one for the CEO and leadership team. 

CFOs who are great at reporting…

  • Use data visualizations to clearly illustrate patterns in the company’s financial data
  • Make the most of analysis tools and dashboards to make reporting more efficient.
  • Connect up the dots for their stakeholders: they flag trends and anomalies in the executive summary, bringing in outside information such as market observations where necessary.
  • Keep an organized backlog of reports on where the company’s finances have been, so they can predict where they’re going. 

7. Streamlining finance processes? 

All CFOs are busy people, but the best ones pick their battles and automate as much as possible. A great finance manager will ensure that there are systems in place for every repetitive task, and invest in technology to tackle admin, from things like creating invoices to chasing unpaid debts. 

Here’s some metrics that indicate you’re good at streamlining processes. 

  • Closing the books takes you closer to 5 days than 15. Your team knows what their roles are in this operation, and the process rarely feels like a mess.  
  • Introducing new tools to put your admin on autopilot. 
  • Being willing to listen when a team member suggests a more efficient way to complete a duty you’ve delegated to them. 
  • Having a team atmosphere of collaboration, rather than frustration and burnout. 

8. Having a strategic vision for the company’s future?

A great CFO is an active business partner to their CEO, and always has an informed perspective on what the next move should be. With their finger on the pulse, they will be the first to spot disruptions such as supply chain issues or economic downturns, and to suggest a course of action. 

Whilst a CFO might favor particular tactics, they’re generally adaptable and good at change management. 

Qualitative performance metrics include: 

  • Being able to point to core strategic decisions for the business that you have influenced. 
  • Offering suggestions to drive the company forwards that go against the ‘business-as-usual’ approach. 
  • Balancing your role as a visionary leader, and a member of a team that’s answerable to a board of directors—some of whom may offer different perspectives. 
  • Being comfortable disagreeing with your CEO when necessary, and diplomatically making a case for tactics you believe will be financial astute. 

9. Budgeting the company’s resources? 

Budgeting skills are essential for any CFO. This includes the prioritization exercise of deciding where to allocate resources, the accounting exercise of balancing so many fixed and variable costs, and the policing exercise of ensuring teams stay within their budgets.

Relevant performance metrics include: 

  • Success at keeping teams on budget, as recorded in profit-loss statements and balance sheets. 
  • Positive (or at least, low negative) budget variance.
  • Making judicious decisions on where to cut the budget, and where to allocate a little more. 

Pro tip
: For most companies, software is the second biggest expenditure after payroll. Therefore, speaking both logically and compassionately, when times get tough, the first budget a CFO should look to cut is the software budget. 

However, this is often an area that escapes scrutiny, since it’s hard to trace exactly how much you’re spending on software licenses. Many companies have no central log of what they’re spending on apps—let alone assessments on whether those apps are delivering ROI. 

SaaS management tool like Cledara can reverse this trend. It’ll help you keep track of all your tools, give you insights into how much you’re spending on them, and even tell you whether your colleagues are using them or not. This means it’s easy to make software budget cuts. 

10. Managing risk? 

From shadow IT to supply chain chaos, a great CFO should also be well-versed in risk management—even where this does not directly connect to financial matters. After all, every threat to the business is a threat to the business’ finances. 

Relevant performance metrics include: 

  • Being able to spot risks associated with changes in market conditions, such as fluctuations in interest rates and commodity prices—and clearly communicating these to stakeholders in good time.
  • Contingency planning for potential risk scenarios, having a plan to carry the company through unfavorable events. 
  • Ensuring compliance with financial regulations and reporting requirements.
  • Diversifying the company’s investment portfolio. 
  • Managing insurance policies to cover specific risks that have a reasonable chance of coming to pass. 

A CFO’s work is never done 

Leading a business to financial success requires a notably long and wide list of skills. It makes perfect sense that the average age of Fortune 500 CFOs, as of 2019, was about 56

This demanding role is typically for finance professionals nearing the end of their careers—people who have seen it all from decades in the workforce, and watched the success or failure of a handful of companies at close range. Perhaps the best performance indicator of a great CFO is the ability to learn from years of hands-on experience. 

What is the biggest indicator of a great CFO?

The biggest indicator of a great CFO is the ability to drive financial strategy and deliver sustainable growth. Metrics like team leadership and risk management are important too, but the most essential success metrics of a CFO is, undoubtedly, a business’ financial health. 

Who should measure the performance of a CFO?

The board of directors and executive leadership team should measure the performance of a CFO. 

How can you measure the performance of a CFO?

Performance of a CFO can be measured by assessing financial results, strategic contributions, and effective risk management. Some metrics like financial results can—and should—be measured numerically, but some of the other performance indicators—such as strategic contributions and team leadership—are better assessed with qualitative judgements. 

What qualities make a great CFO?

Qualities that make a great CFO include strong financial acumen, strategic vision, effective communication skills, and the ability to adapt to changing business environments.



Subscribe to our newsletter

Receive the latest insights in your inbox

Miranda Gabbott

Miranda is a writer and content marketer with over five years’ experience writing about software, predominantly for SaaS companies such as Hotjar, Typeform and Preply. She’s interested in ethical and cultural considerations around new technologies and is currently studying for an MA in Design for Responsible AI.

Share this post

Subscribe to our newsletter and stay informed on the latest SaaS insights

Explore more

Explore more

The Top Accounts Receivable Software for 2024: Upflow vs Chaser

Here’s everything you need to know if you’re in the market for accounts receivable software and want to make the best choice, with a focus on Invoiced and Chaser, two leading options.
Read more

How Scaleups Can Maximize Software ROI in 2024

Wondering how to improve software ROI for your company? In this post, you’ll learn everything you need to know to drive maximum ROI from software investments.
Read more

A Comprehensive Guide to Key Performance Indicators for CFOs

Here’s 23 KPIs CFOs should track in order to gain a full overview of their business’ financial health.
Read more

14 Smart Strategies to Reduce IT Costs as a CFO

Software is typically a company’s second biggest expense after payroll, so here are 14 actionable ways to get your spending under control and reduce IT costs.
Read more

10 Must-Have Software Tools for CFOs

According to Cledara’s data, these software tools for CFOs are absolutely invaluable. Save time, reduce errors and increase compliance with these programs.
Read more

The Complete Guide to Forecasting SaaS Costs for 2024

As we enter 2024, accurately forecasting SaaS costs is more critical than ever for CFOs. With tightened funding, volatile markets, and increasing SaaS expenditures, getting your 2024 projections right has major implications. This comprehensive guide equips you with the key strategies to master SaaS cost forecasting.
Read more

Financial Planning and Analysis (FP&A) Top 10 Software Tools

Interested in learning how to enhance your FP&A strategy with the right software tools? This guide is here to help.
Read more

Why Treasury and Cash Management Software Is Essential in 2023 [+ Best Tools]

Treasury and cash management are crucial to financial planning. Discover key tools and strategies to optimize your cash management in 2023's unique landscape.
Read more

Budget Reporting: The Ultimate Guide

Budget reporting is the comparison, analysis, and documentation of the current company's financial performance against the projected budget.
Read more

The Rise of Embedded Finance

From Uber to Amazon, companies are integrating financial products into their offerings through embedded finance.
Read more

Accounting SaaS Comparison: Xero vs Sage vs Quickbooks

Looking to replace your current accounting SaaS tool? In this post, we compare Xero vs Sage vs Quickbooks, exploring features, pricing, integrations & more.
Read more

9 Ways Financial Reporting Software Can Help Companies Save More Money

Discover how financial reporting software can help startups save money and streamline operations. With features like expense tracking, account reconciliation, cash flow management, and more, businesses can become more efficient and profitable. Invest in financial reporting software to secure your startup's future.
Read more

How to Hire Fractional CFO Services in 2023

Considering outsourcing CFO services? In this guide, you'll learn everything you need to know to hire a great fractional CFO.
Read more

FinOps Principles for Scaleup Finance Leaders: The Definitive Guide

Strategically implementing FinOps principles can help you bring clarity and efficiency to your scaleup's finances. Here's how to get it done.
Read more

Startup Costs: How Much Should a Startup Spend on Software?

Want to optimize your startup costs? Get key insights into software budget allocation in this post.
Read more